TL;DR
Get everyday helpers delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
A woman receiving daily IV nutrition after a post-surgical condition wrote that strangers at a community cookout criticized her weight and pressured her to eat. Advice columnist R. Eric Thomas said she was being bullied and did not owe them details of her medical history. The account does not identify the woman or say whether she plans to return to community events.
In a letter to Thomas, the woman said her condition requires daily intravenous nutrition and has caused her to lose a considerable amount of weight. She wrote that she enjoys food but cannot eat much. At the cookout, she brought a dish, sampled some of the food and said she was glad to meet people in her community while feeling well enough to socialize.
She said several women she had never met told her she was too skinny and needed to eat more. After she declined extra food, two women placed a filled plate in front of her and continued commenting on her appearance, including comparing her to a “gangly young boy.” She said she knew eating more could make her sick, kept declining and left before she began to cry.
The woman asked whether she should have explained her medical history. Thomas replied that her polite refusal was sufficient, and that she did not owe strangers further information. He suggested that, if the women approached her again, she could state directly that comments about her body were unwelcome.
Medical Privacy at Community Gatherings
The account highlights how unsolicited remarks about weight can turn an ordinary social gathering into a distressing experience, particularly for someone managing a health condition. The woman said she wanted to become more active in her community as her strength improved, but worried about facing further body shaming.
Thomas’s response centers on personal boundaries and privacy: the woman could decline food without explaining why. The column does not report a broader policy change or medical finding; its focus is advice to one letter writer about handling an encounter with strangers.
Popular right now
Philips 5500 Series Fully Automatic Espresso Machine with LatteGo
Shark Navigator Lift-Away Upright Vacuum (NV360)
Dyson V8 Cyclone Cordless Vacuum
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
What Happened at the Cookout
The woman described attending a neighborhood cookout to meet people and participate while recovering enough to socialize. She said she tasted several dishes and expressed appreciation for the food and company, but the women continued to press her after she declined more.
Her letter did not name the location, the other attendees or the medical condition behind her need for IV nutrition. The account appears as part of the “Asking Eric” advice column in Seniors Guide, with Thomas answering the letter under the name “Skinny and Hungry.”
““I feel as though politely declining extra food should have been sufficient and I don’t feel as though I need to disclose my condition to defend myself.””
— The letter writer, as quoted in the column
Details the Letter Leaves Open
The column does not disclose the woman’s identity, the specific post-surgical condition, where the cookout took place or whether anyone else intervened. It also does not say whether she has since attended another gathering or spoken with the women again.
The women’s perspective is not included, so their intentions and recollection of the exchange are unreported. Thomas said they may have thought they had good intentions, while judging their repeated comments and pressure to eat as bullying.
Returning to Community Events
Thomas encouraged the woman not to let the encounter keep her away from social gatherings and suggested using a clear boundary if the comments recur. The column gives no indication of what she will decide or whether the community will respond.
The published advice is directed to the letter writer; no follow-up or additional reporting on the incident is provided in the source material.
Key Questions
What happened at the cookout?
A 54-year-old woman said strangers criticized her weight and urged her to eat despite her repeated refusals. She left after the comments continued.
Why had the woman lost weight?
She wrote that a post-surgical medical condition requires daily IV nutrition and has caused considerable weight loss. The column does not name the condition.
Did the columnist say she had to explain her medical history?
No. R. Eric Thomas said she did not owe strangers more than the response she had already given when declining food.
What did Thomas suggest if the comments happen again?
He suggested telling the women that comments about her body are unwelcome and that she will not tolerate more of them.
Source: rss
